July 20th, 2009 at 11:11 AM

On the Kit and on the Mic: 10 Singing Drummers

philcollins

Drumming in a rock ‘n’ roll band — or any band — has its own challenges. They call it limb independence, but until you’ve tried to keep one time with the right side of your body and a different time with the left, it’s hard to appreciate the skill that the best rock drummers bring to the table. It looks easy, but it isn’t. More difficult, still, is to sing lead while your hands and feet are keeping the beat. Here’s a tribute to ten drummers who not only keep the rhythm but serve up the lyrics, too.

1. Peter Criss, Kiss
Although Peter Criss is best remembered for the ballad “Beth,” his raspy vocals turned Paul Stanley’s “Black Diamond” into the heaviest song in the Kiss catalog, and that same rasp makes “Hard Luck Woman” the band’ best “folk” tune.
Cool Deep Track: “Hooligan” from Love Gun

2. Phil Collins, Genesis (pictured)
Even before Peter Gabriel departed Genesis, Phil Collins’ vocal abilities were coming to the front on tunes such as “For Absent Friends” on 1971’s Nursery Cryme. Later, Collins became the voice of Genesis, all the while playing some amazing drums.
Cool Deep Track: “Eleventh Earl Of Mar” from Wind & Wuthering

3. Levon Helm, The Band
Levon Helm’s musical talents extend far beyond the drum kit, being a capable guitarist and mandolin player, too. But it was Helm who anchored the earthy songs of The Band, and sang lead on some of the group’s most memorable material including “The Night They Drove Dixie Down.”
Cool Deep Track: “The Caves Of Jericho” from Jericho

4. Gil Moore, Triumph
Moore shared the vocal duties in Triumph with guitarist Rik Emmett and was the go-to-guy for wall-busting rockers. Moore played a prodigious kit, and watching him drum and swing the mic stand as he sang and moved around the set was humbling for someone that wanted to be just a drummer.
Cool Deep Track: “Tear The Roof Off” from Progressions Of Power

5. Don Henley, The Eagles
The Eagles were never short of vocal talent, with every member that’s passed through the band grabbing hold of the mic on at least one song. Drummer Don Henley sang lead on a bevy of the band’s hits, including “One Of These Nights,” “Hotel California,” “Witchy Woman,” “Best Of My Love” and “The Long Run.”
Cool Deep Track: “Doolin-Dalton” from Desperado


6. Kelly Keagy, Night Ranger
While Jack Blades was assuring teen-aged boys that they could still rock in America, Night Ranger drummer Kelly Keagy was making the girls swoon on “Sentimental Street” and “Goodbye.” And is there a better power ballad than “Sister Christian”? All together now, fists in the air, “You’re motoring. What’s your price for flight?!”
Cool Deep Track: “Sister Christian.” Just kidding. Check out “New York Time” from Neverland

7. Walter Orange, The Commodores
If your only memory of The Commodores is Lionel Richie singing “I’m Easy,” think again. Remember a salacious little song about a lady who had it going on? Who was really stacked? Like a “Brick House”? That nasty number features Commodores’ drummer Walter Orange on the mic.
Cool Deep Track: “Slippery When Wet” from Caught In The Act

8. Pete Rivera, Rare Earth
Rare Earth were rare indeed, a band composed of all white members and signed to Motown Records. Rare Earth’s blend of rock, funk and R&B seemed a perfect fit, though, for Berry Gordy’s burgeoning record label. Thanks to drummer Pete Rivera’s soulful vocals, the group charted hits including “Get Ready” and “I Just Want To Celebrate.”
Cool Deep Track: “Ma” from Ma.

9. Ringo Starr, The Beatles
Ringo Starr may have been the odd man out in The Beatles, but he was a very under-rated drummer and singer. Sometimes you need the levity of an “Octopus’s Garden” to balance the cryptic musings of “Come Together.”
Cool Deep Track: “Don’t Pass Me By” from The White Album

10. Roger Taylor, Queen
Queen’s sound had as much to do with Roger Taylor as it did Freddie Mercury. Behind the kit, Taylor not only played terrific drums, he sang harmony on countless Queen classics and lead on several of the band’s hardest-rocking numbers. “Sheer Heart Attack” is full-on punk rock, and if Taylor’s singing on “I’m In Love With My Car” doesn’t put you in a trance, you have no soul.
Cool deep track: “The Loser In The End” from Queen II

Comments

7
  1. July 20th, 2009 at 11:51 AM { # }

    Frank Deserto said:

    I admit, I have a huge problem with drummers who are also lead vocalist, but I can’t deny my love for Death From Above 1979, Low, or uh… the Carpenters.

  2. July 20th, 2009 at 11:51 AM { # }

    natty said:

    Nice tribute! The drummer in my old band was also our singer. It definitely makes for more challenges to engage the audience, but it can totally work!

  3. July 20th, 2009 at 11:51 AM { # }

    Kim said:

    This is a great list. I have been a Phil Collins fan for a long time – and Tarzan notwithstanding, you can’t say the man isn’t really freaking talented. I knew about Ringo and Levon but there are a bunch here I did not know about. Thank you!

  4. July 20th, 2009 at 11:51 AM { # }

    Sharon Reaper said:

    Phil Collins rocks. The man is a genius. Caught the tail-end of a documentary on TV the other day – very informative.

    Watched the genius progress from Genesis to Phil Collins to Genesis full circle. Also love the acting, in addition to the music and drums – everything really.

  5. July 20th, 2009 at 11:51 AM { # }

    Joe said:

    Christian Vander of Magma!

  6. July 20th, 2009 at 11:51 AM { # }

    Anton Partonen said:

    Yes, Phil Collins is the man. He’s done so many hits and still saying i’m drummer who sings a little bit.
    I don’t know any who is so talent in drums and still is so good singing.

  7. July 20th, 2009 at 11:51 AM { # }

    eggopm3 said:

    Good list with one glaring omission: Andy Sturmer of Jellyfish. Not only did he sing and play drums, but he did it standing up using a specially customized drum kit.

March 19th, 2010 at 2:36 AM